“Of
all the stupid portmanteau terms we had come across while reading
magazines- manthropology, shoemaggedon, hiberdating- 'vagenda' was
the most ridiculous. And we found not only that the amalgamation of
'vagina' and 'agenda' was pleasing to the ear, but that the word
perfectly encapsulated the aims of the blog: to expose the silly,
manipulative and sometimes damaging ulterior motives of women's
magazines.”
-The
Vagenda
As mentioned recently,
an advance copy of The Vagenda, a book described by writer /
broadcaster Jeanette Winterson as “A brilliant expose of women's
mags and marketing- laugh-out-loud” landed in my corridor . I have
quite omnivorous tastes when it comes to literature, but I've never
read any women's lifestyle magazines so the book was an insightful
introduction to this world of advice, tips and “true” stories.
From
a male perspective, the book reassured me that women were being fed
as much crap in lifestyle magazines as men are- I'd always felt that
mags like FHM and Loaded were childish affairs for people too scared
to reach for the top shelf, and that the more upmarket publications
like GQ and Esquire were for people with waaaay more money than me. I
felt that a lot of the information from both ends of the men's
lifestyle spectrum wasn't that interesting, or the “advice”
wasn't particularly helpful.
That said, the chapter on lads' mags I found to be a little patronising. Yes, some of their humour borders on outright misogyny, but the writers forget that humour has and always will push the boundaries of what is acceptable, and humour- including sexual jokes- will always be one of those boundaries. The onus, the writers seem to forget, is on the individuals not to be a misogynist themselves.
That said, the chapter on lads' mags I found to be a little patronising. Yes, some of their humour borders on outright misogyny, but the writers forget that humour has and always will push the boundaries of what is acceptable, and humour- including sexual jokes- will always be one of those boundaries. The onus, the writers seem to forget, is on the individuals not to be a misogynist themselves.
The
revelation that The Vagenda delivers is one that relates to men's and
women's magazines, and having read many Esquires and the occasional
Loaded in my time, I'm embarrassed not to have realised this myself.
If these magazines could actually help you, if their advice was sound
and beneficial, you wouldn't need to buy their magazines any more. So
they feed you rubbish and keep you in the dark to keep you spending.
Written
by journalists Holly Baxter and Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett in a funny but
professional tone, The Vagenda brings insight and laughs, but also
sheds light on the way the media portrays women as an entire gender,
or as they put it “being labelled frigid, princesses or tramps”.
The style is a little familiar, similar to a lot of other successful
blogs written by women with journalism backgrounds- Arsenic and Old Lace and Bookcunt for example, both fine feminist blogs
with I suspect some professional training behind them- but The
Vagenda's material is consistently engaging, and stretches its
investigations further than just reprinting sections of the blog as a
book (Not that we're criticising, Belle De Jour.)
Editors
and advertisers- people who create the magazines of today- are
clearly under increasing scrutiny to respect their audiences, and to
market towards them with understanding and dignity (not least by The
Vagenda writers themselves). This book will hopefully push things
forward in that regard. It'll also make you laugh in the process.
The Vagenda is released 5th March. Advanced copies available online.
No comments:
Post a Comment